The Internet's AI Trust Standard

How we rate the internet

  1. Red rangeHigh risk1.0–3.9 / F
  2. Orange rangeUse caution4.0–6.9 / C–D
  3. Silver rangeGenerally trusted7.0–8.9 / B
  4. Gold rangeHigh trust9.0–10.0 / A

See ShouldEye at work

AI modes

Made-up examples, shown to explain how ShouldEye works.

Deep search verdict

gadgetvault.example

Made-up example

Popular Deep Search

VerdictIs it legit?

EyeQ picks 5 engines. One Verdict report.
Verdict reportUse caution4.4 out of 10 · Grade D
  1. The verdictUse caution. A real store, but too new and too quiet to trust with a big order.
  2. The reasoningSeven months old, five-star reviews from one week, and twelve open complaints.
  3. The agreementFour of five engines back it. One called it safe.

Pay by card, and only what you could afford to lose.

Every rating shows the evidence behind it, and nothing here was paid for.

See ShouldEye at work

Checks

Made-up examples, shown to explain how ShouldEye works.

Site rating

shop.example

Made-up example

Use caution

Orange range

4.6Score out of 10 · Grade D

Check the flagged items before you pay.

  • Owner hidden behind a privacy serviceConcern
  • Refunds limited to store credit, stated only in the termsConcern
  • Late-delivery complaints rising for three monthsConcern
  • Secure checkout with card buyer protectionGood
  • Support replied within one working dayGood

Every rating shows the evidence behind it, and nothing here was paid for.

Why we exist

Search made the internet findable. We make it trustworthy.

  • 54signals read before any site is rated
  • 9areas, each one a question you would ask
  • 4ranges, from red to gold
  • 0ratings for sale. Not one, not ever.

The past and the future

Search gives you links. We give you the truth.

Search made the web findable, and finding is no longer the problem. The first screen is ads, the next is pages written to rank, and somewhere below sits the business you wanted, next to its imitators. Nothing on that page says which one is safe. That is the job we do.

The past · Search

  • shop.example · Official siteSponsored
  • Deals like shop.example, up to 80% offSponsored
  • Is shop.example legit? Honest review
  • shop.example outlet store · Official clearance
  • shop.example coupons and promo codes
  • shop.example customer service number

Two ads, one copycat, three guesses. The checking is left to you.

The future · ShouldEye

  • Rates the business behind the pageSearch ranks pages by how well they match your words.
  • Sells no ratings, everSearch sells the top of the page as advertising.
  • Flags look-alikes, fake shops and invented reviewsSearch shows real businesses and convincing copies side by side.
  • Gives you one grade, with the evidence behind itSearch hands you ten links to investigate yourself.
  • Reads the fine print for youSearch leaves the terms, refund rules and privacy policy for you to read.

The Trust Range

Four ranges. One standard for everyone.

Everything we rate ends in the same place: a score from 1 to 10, a grade from A to F, and one of four stamps you can read at a glance.

  1. Red

    High risk

    1.0–3.9 / F

    Serious warning signs. Stop before you pay or share personal details, and read the evidence first.

  2. Orange

    Use caution

    4.0–6.9 / C–D

    Real concerns sit beside some good signals. Check the flagged items before you commit.

  3. Silver

    Generally trusted

    7.0–8.9 / B

    A solid record with minor gaps. Note the few items marked for attention.

  4. Gold

    High trust

    9.0–10.0 / A

    Clear ownership, fair policies and a long, consistent record. The strongest result the standard gives.

Trust grade1–10 / A–F

Inside the trust engine

The engine never stops reading. Ratings move when the truth does.

Five steps turn any address into a rating, and the last one loops back to the first.

  1. 01

    Gather

    We collect public evidence: the site itself, its policies, ownership records, dispute outcomes and reports from people who used it.

  2. 02

    Verify

    Claims are checked against independent sources. What a company says about itself counts for less than what it can be seen doing.

  3. 03

    Score

    Each signal is scored against the same published standard. A long, steady record weighs more than a recent spike.

  4. 04

    Publish

    The range, the grade and the signals behind them appear together, so you can see why a site landed where it did.

  5. 05

    Keep watching

    Ratings are revisited when policies change, complaints rise or ownership moves. A grade is never final.

    Loops back to 01

shop.example, over one year

Made-up example
  1. A year ago7.4Generally trusted
  2. Today4.6Use caution
  1. Refunds moved to store credit only, stated in the terms
  2. Late-delivery complaints started rising
  3. The owner moved behind a privacy service

The score moved because the evidence moved. Nobody paid for it, and nobody could.

What we check · 54 signals in 9 areas

Nine questions you would ask. We answer every one.

We read a site the way a careful customer would if they had weeks to spare. Pick a question to see the signals behind it.

01 · Ownership and identity

Who is behind it?

6 of 54 signals

  • Legal entity name and company registration
  • A physical address that exists and matches the registration
  • Named owners or leadership, not a privacy shield alone
  • Domain age, ownership history and recent transfers
  • Business details that match across site, registry and card statement
  • Sudden rebrands, renames or a trail of closed companies

Truth first

Five promises. Kept on every rating.

A rating only keeps you safe if it arrives before the mistake, comes with reasons, and cannot be bought by the company it describes.

  1. § 01

    No paid placement

    A company cannot buy a better score, a higher range or the removal of a fair finding.

  2. § 02

    One standard for everyone

    The largest platform and the newest shop are measured against the same published rules.

  3. § 03

    Evidence with every rating

    No bare verdicts. Each range comes with the signals that produced it.

  4. § 04

    Ratings that move

    When a company changes how it behaves, its range changes with it, in either direction.

  5. § 05

    Honest about limits

    A rating is guidance based on evidence. It is not legal advice or a guarantee, and the signals are there for you to judge.

Truth first

Before you trust it, rate it.

Check a site before you trust it, or read exactly how every score is calculated.